| # | Name | Rank | Elevation | Prominence | Counties | Quadrangle |
| 1 | Garden Mountain | 6 | 4,710' | 2,140' | Tazewell | Hutchinson Rock |
| 2 | Beartown Mountain | 7 | 4,689' | 1,509' | Russell | Elk Garden |
| 3 | Highland County HP | 12 | 4,546' | 396' | Highland & Pocahontas | Hightown |
| 4 | Paddy Knob | 14 | 4,477' | 1,297' | Bath, Highland, & Pocahontas | Paddy Knob |
| 5 | Elliott Knob | 15 | 4,463' | 2,443' | Augusta | Elliott Knob |
| 6 | Chestnut Ridge | 20 | 4,409' | 629' | Bland & Tazewell | Hutchinson Rock |
| 7 | Flagpole Knob | 26 | 4,380' | 680' | Rockingham | Brandywine |
| 8 | Salt Pond Mountain | 27 | 4,361' | 2,061' | Giles | Eggleston |
| 9 | Apple Orchard Mountain | 38 | 4,225' | 2,823' | Bedford & Botetourt | Arnold Valley |
| 10 | High Knob | 41 | 4,223' | 2,053' | Wise | Norton |
| 11 | Comers Rock | 62 | 4,100' | 600' | Grayson & Wythe | Speedwell |
| 12 | Doubles, The | 4,100' | 240' | Harlan & Wise | Benham | |
| 13 | Wrights Peak | 70 | 4,073' | 1,243' | Giles & Monroe | Interior |
| 14 | Rocky Mountain | 71 | 4,072' | 2,282' | Amherst & Rockbridge | Montebello |
| 15 | Big Knob | 72 | 4,072' | 972' | Alleghany | Covington |
| 16 | Buckhorn Knob | 73 | 4,069' | 759' | Bland, Giles, & Mercer | Oakvale |
| 17 | Priest, The | 74 | 4,063' | 763' | Nelson | Massies Mill |
| 18 | Hawksbill | 87 | 4,050' | 2,148' | Madison & Page | Big Meadows |