| # | Peak | Elevation | Prominence | State | Counties | Quadrangle |
| 1 | Horsetooth Mountain | 7,255' | 595' | CO | Larimer | Horsetooth Reservoir - Map |
| 2 | 5934 | 5,934' | 394' | CO | Larimer | Horsetooth Reservoir - Map |
| 3 | "Aggie Peak" | 5,773' | 333' | CO | Larimer | Horsetooth Reservoir - Map |
| 4 | "Duncan's Ridge" | 5,740' | 80' | CO | Larimer | Horsetooth Reservoir - Map |
| 5 | Reservoir Benchmark | 5,735' | 305' | CO | Larimer | Horsetooth Reservoir - Map |