| List Rank | ID Rank | Name | Elevation | Saddle | Prominence | Line Parent | Isolation | Proximate Parent | County | Quadrangle |
| 1 | 4522 | Lincoln County HP | 5,950' | 5,510' | 440' | Johnson Benchmark | 9.31 | Johnson Benchmark | Camas & Lincoln | Thorn Creek Reservoir - Map |
| Black Butte Hills | 5,130' | 5,010' | 120' | Lincoln County HP | 5.66 | Lincoln County HP | Lincoln | Summit Reservoir - Map | ||
| 2 | 5157 | Spud Butte | 5,013' | 4,710' | 303' | 6368 | 8.52 | Laidlaw Butte | Lincoln | Wagon Butte - Map |
| 4984 | 4,984' | 4,688' | 296' | Wedge Butte | 5.82 | 5273 | Lincoln | Shoshone Ice Cave - Map | ||
| Sand Butte | 4,974' | 4,750' | 224' | 6368 | 10.65 | Laidlaw Butte | Lincoln | Wagon Butte - Map | ||
| Broken Top Butte | 4,957' | 4,850' | 107' | 6368 | 10.25 | Laidlaw Butte | Lincoln | Wagon Butte - Map | ||
| 3 | 5190 | Kinzie Butte | 4,945' | 4,545' | 400' | Lincoln County HP | 9.57 | Dinosaur Ridge | Lincoln | Kinzie Butte - Map |
| 4 | 5204 | Wildhorse Butte | 4,915' | 4,570' | 345' | 6368 | 13.23 | Laidlaw Butte | Lincoln | Halfway Lake - Map |
| Monument Butte | 4,870' | 4,670' | 200' | 6368 | 9.76 | Queens Crown | Lincoln | Pagari Well - Map | ||
| Johnson Butte | 4,868' | 4,630' | 238' | Wedge Butte | 6.86 | Kinzie Butte | Lincoln | Richfield - Map | ||
| Black Butte Crater | 4,850' | 4,690' | 160' | Lincoln County HP | 3.52 | Dinosaur Ridge | Lincoln | Shoshone Ice Cave - Map | ||
| 5 | 5264 | Sid Butte | 4,775' | 4,345' | 430' | Kimama Butte | 6.70 | Kimama Butte | Lincoln | Kimama Butte - Map |
| Black Ridge Crater | 4,679' | 4,450' | 229' | Wildhorse Butte | 9.47 | Wildhorse Butte | Lincoln | Black Ridge Crater - Map | ||
| 6 | 5330 | 4645 | 4,645' | 4,305' | 340' | Fissure Butte | 11.86 | Kimama Butte | Lincoln | Norland - Map |
| 7 | 5335 | Dietrich Butte | 4,632' | 4,190' | 442' | 6368 | 11.83 | Kinzie Butte | Lincoln | Dietrich Butte - Map |
| Shale Butte | 4,578' | 4,450' | 128' | Wildhorse Butte | 5.05 | Wildhorse Butte | Lincoln | Shale Butte - Map | ||
| Lava WSA HP | 4,550' | 4,530' | 20' | Wedge Butte | 4.07 | Kinzie Butte | Lincoln | Shoshone Ice Cave - Map | ||
| Crater, The | 4,485' | 4,325' | 160' | Kimama Butte | 5.03 | Kimama Butte | Lincoln | Kimama - Map | ||
| Owinza Butte | 4,436' | 4,255' | 181' | Sid Butte | 5.35 | Sid Butte | Lincoln | Owinza Butte - Map | ||
| Crater Butte | 4,432' | 4,275' | 157' | Dietrich Butte | 2.86 | Dietrich Butte | Lincoln | Dietrich - Map | ||
| Wilson Butte | 4,387' | 4,115' | 272' | Kimama Butte | 11.14 | Dietrich Butte | Jerome | Star Lake - Map | ||
| 8 | 5457 | Notch Butte | 4,335' | 3,985' | 350' | Dietrich Butte | 11.15 | Dietrich Butte | Lincoln | Shoshone - Map |
| Brown Butte | 4,300' | 4,190' | 110' | Dietrich Butte | 3.64 | Dietrich Butte | Lincoln | Dietrich Butte - Map | ||
| Shoshone WSA HP | 3,975' | 3,965' | 10' | Wedge Butte | 6.24 | Notch Butte | Lincoln | Shoshone - Map |