| # | Name | Elevation | Prominence | Isolation | Counties | Quadrangle |
| 1 | Julian, Mount | 12,932' | 1,227' | 7.20 | Larimer | Grand Lake |
| 2 | Ida, Mount | 12,882' | 514' | 1.12 | Grand & Larimer | Grand Lake |
| 3 | Howard Mountain | 12,826' | 871' | 2.93 | Grand & Jackson | Mount Richthofen |
| 4 | 12819 | 12,819' | 391' | 0.68 | Grand & Larimer | Grand Lake |
| 5 | Cirrus, Mount | 12,808' | 400' | 0.56 | Grand & Jackson | Mount Richthofen |
| 6 | Cumulus, Mount | 12,729' | 400' | 0.97 | Grand & Jackson | Mount Richthofen |
| 7 | Comanche Peak Wilderness HP | 12,722' | 1,443' | 5.04 | Larimer | Comanche Peak |
| 8 | Nimbus, Mount | 12,721' | 623' | 1.14 | Grand | Mount Richthofen |
| 9 | Sprague Mountain | 12,709' | 552' | 1.04 | Grand & Larimer | McHenrys Peak |
| 10 | Andrews Peak | 12,571' | 1,197' | 2.39 | Grand | Isolation Peak |
| 11 | Lead Mountain | 12,546' | 465' | 0.98 | Grand & Jackson | Mount Richthofen |
| 12 | Sharkstooth, The | 12,531' | 394' | 0.52 | Larimer | McHenrys Peak |
| 13 | Specimen Mountain | 12,490' | 1,743' | 4.68 | Grand & Larimer | Fall River Pass |
| 14 | Chapin, Mount | 12,455' | 398' | 1.81 | Larimer | Trail Ridge |
| 15 | "Never Summer Peak" | 12,447' | 463' | 0.49 | Grand | Mount Richthofen |
| 16 | Watanga Mountain | 12,377' | 610' | 1.18 | Grand | Isolation Peak |
| 17 | "Trail Ridge" | 12,349' | 519' | 2.87 | Larimer | Fall River Pass |
| 18 | 12314 | 12,314' | 375' | 1.61 | Larimer | Comanche Peak |
| 19 | "North Specimen" | 12,305' | 381' | 0.61 | Grand & Larimer | Fall River Pass |
| 20 | "Dundicking" | 12,295' | 316' | 1.85 | Larimer | Estes Park |
| 21 | Snowdrift Peak | 12,273' | 746' | 2.53 | Grand | McHenrys Peak |
| 22 | Fall Mountain | 12,270' | 347' | 1.98 | Larimer | Comanche Peak |
| 23 | "Fleur De Lis" | 12,253' | 327' | 1.46 | Grand | Isolation Peak |
| 24 | "Ptarmigans Beak" | 12,246' | 369' | 0.78 | Grand | Isolation Peak |
| 25 | Nakai Peak | 12,238' | 643' | 1.45 | Grand | Grand Lake |
| 26 | Sugarloaf Mountain | 12,199' | 324' | 2.36 | Larimer | Pingree Park |
| 27 | Adams, Mount | 12,124' | 307' | 1.47 | Grand | Isolation Peak |
| 28 | Thunder Mountain | 12,056' | 410' | 0.56 | Grand, Jackson, & Larimer | Fall River Pass |
| 29 | Craig, Mount | 12,025' | 388' | 1.21 | Grand | Isolation Peak |
| 30 | Twin Peaks, East | 11,943' | 633' | 1.72 | Grand | Shadow Mountain |
| 31 | "Poudre Peak" | 11,859' | 444' | 2.02 | Larimer | Fall River Pass |
| 32 | "Roaring Peak" | 11,721' | 314' | 0.68 | Grand | Isolation Peak |
| 33 | Jackstraw Mountain | 11,713' | 512' | 2.07 | Grand | Fall River Pass |
| 34 | Patterson, Mount | 11,430' | 629' | 2.46 | Grand | Grand Lake |
| 35 | Twin Sisters Peaks, East | 11,429' | 2,296' | 5.38 | Larimer | Longs Peak |
| 36 | "Confluence Peak" | 11,203' | 775' | 2.81 | Larimer | Trail Ridge |
| 37 | Joe Mills Mountain | 11,087' | 478' | 1.64 | Larimer | McHenrys Peak |
| 38 | "Pennock Peak" | 11,075' | 360' | 1.78 | Larimer | Pingree Park |
| 39 | Estes Cone | 11,009' | 772' | 2.67 | Larimer | Longs Peak |
| 40 | "Gray Jay Mountain" | 10,982' | 544' | 2.08 | Grand | Grand Lake |
| 41 | Dark Mountain | 10,864' | 416' | 2.45 | Larimer | Estes Park |
| 42 | "Nutcracker Peak" | 10,849' | 346' | 1.61 | Larimer | Trail Ridge |
| 43 | Wuh, Mount | 10,767' | 426' | 1.12 | Larimer | McHenrys Peak |
| 44 | Lookout Mountain | 10,729' | 321' | 2.59 | Boulder | Allens Park |
| 45 | "Lightning Peak" | 10,573' | 414' | 0.67 | Larimer | Longs Peak |
| 46 | McGregor Mountain | 10,482' | 962' | 1.33 | Larimer | Estes Park |
| 47 | Wescott, Mount | 10,438' | 322' | 1.49 | Grand | Shadow Mountain |
| 48 | Green Mountain | 10,329' | 888' | 1.85 | Grand | Grand Lake |
| 49 | "Bushwhack Hill" | 10,191' | 422' | 1.67 | Grand | Grand Lake |
| 50 | "Thunder Peak" | 10,144' | 576' | 0.66 | Larimer | Longs Peak |
| 51 | Needles, The | 10,062' | 943' | 1.37 | Larimer | Estes Park |
| 52 | Deer Mountain | 10,027' | 1,109' | 2.41 | Larimer | Estes Park |
| 53 | Sheep Mountain | 9,794' | 303' | 1.95 | Larimer | Estes Park |
| 54 | "Cascade Falls Point" | 9,723' | 423' | 1.93 | Grand | Grand Lake |
| 55 | Emerald Mountain | 9,234' | 549' | 1.57 | Larimer | Longs Peak |
| 56 | "Gem Peak" | 9,144' | 347' | 2.08 | Larimer | Estes Park |
| 57 | Eagle Cliff Mountain | 8,902' | 669' | 1.49 | Larimer | Longs Peak |
| 58 | Castle Mountain | 8,830' | 537' | 1.79 | Larimer | Estes Park |