| # | Name | Rank | Elevation | Prominence | Counties | Quadrangle |
| 1 | Black Dome | 33 | 3,990' | 2,080' | Greene | Freehold |
| 2 | Blake Peak | 34 | 3,986' | 591' | Essex | Dix Mountain |
| 3 | MacNaughton Mountain | 35 | 3,982' | 849' | Essex | Street Mountain |
| 4 | Blackhead | 37 | 3,950' | 520' | Greene | Freehold |
| 5 | Thomas Cole Mountain | 3,950' | 220' | Greene | Hensonville | |
| 6 | Cliff Mountain | 38 | 3,943' | 482' | Essex | Mount Marcy |
| 7 | Snowy Mountain | 39 | 3,899' | 2,243' | Hamilton | Snowy Mountain |
| 8 | West Kill Mountain | 42 | 3,890' | 1,240' | Greene | Lexington |
| 9 | Nye Mountain | 3,887' | 131' | Essex | Street Mountain | |
| 10 | Doubletop Mountain | 46 | 3,870' | 1,200' | Ulster | Seager |
| 11 | Cornell Mountain | 47 | 3,870' | 620' | Ulster | Phoenicia |
| 12 | Graham Mountain | 48 | 3,868' | 898' | Ulster | Seager |
| 13 | Plateau Mountain | 52 | 3,850' | 1,780' | Greene | Hunter |
| 14 | Table Mountain | 53 | 3,847' | 657' | Ulster | Peekamoose Mountain |
| 15 | Peekamoose Mountain | 3,843' | 193' | Ulster | Peekamoose Mountain | |
| 16 | Lyon Mountain | 56 | 3,830' | 2,247' | Clinton | Moffitsville |
| 17 | Sugarloaf Mountain | 58 | 3,810' | 1,200' | Greene | Hunter |
| 18 | Couchsachraga Peak | 3,792' | 266' | Essex | Santanoni Peak | |
| 19 | Wittenberg Mountain | 3,790' | 240' | Ulster | Phoenicia | |
| 20 | Wakely Mountain | 63 | 3,766' | 1,631' | Hamilton | Wakely Mountain |
| 21 | Blue Mountain | 64 | 3,759' | 1,939' | Hamilton | Blue Mountain Lake |
| 22 | "Southwest Hunter Mountain" | 3,750' | 200' | Greene | Hunter | |
| 23 | Panther Mountain | 65 | 3,730' | 980' | Ulster | Shandaken |
| 24 | Balsam Lake Mountain | 67 | 3,730' | 480' | Ulster | Seager |
| 25 | Lone Mountain | S | 3,721' | 291' | Ulster | Peekamoose Mountain |
| 26 | Big Indian Mountain | 70 | 3,710' | 520' | Ulster | Shandaken |
| 27 | Friday Mountain | 3,694' | 204' | Ulster | West Shokan | |
| 28 | Rusk Mountain | 73 | 3,690' | 760' | Greene | Lexington |
| 29 | Hurricane Mountain | 75 | 3,677' | 1,988' | Essex | Rocky Peak Ridge |
| 30 | High Peak | 76 | 3,655' | 1,705' | Greene | Kaaterskill |
| 31 | Twin Mountain, North | 77 | 3,650' | 840' | Greene | Hunter |
| 32 | Fir Mountain | 79 | 3,630' | 440' | Ulster | Shandaken |
| 33 | Balsam Cap | 3,623' | 253' | Ulster | West Shokan | |
| 34 | Saddleback Mountain | 82 | 3,615' | 1,270' | Essex | Jay Mountain |
| 35 | Pillsbury Mountain | 84 | 3,612' | 1,083' | Hamilton | Spruce Lake |
| 36 | "Bearpen Mountain" | 85 | 3,610' | 1,700' | Greene | Prattsville |
| 37 | North Dome | 86 | 3,610' | 1,160' | Greene | Lexington |
| 38 | Balsam Mountain | 87 | 3,610' | 580' | Ulster | Shandaken |
| 39 | Eagle Mountain | 88 | 3,610' | 500' | Ulster | Seager |
| 40 | Indian Head Mountain | 92 | 3,573' | 463' | Greene | Woodstock |
| 41 | Gore Mountain | 93 | 3,572' | 1,870' | Warren | Gore Mountain |
| 42 | Noonmark Mountain | 94 | 3,556' | 784' | Essex | Keene Valley |
| 43 | Sherrill, Mount | 95 | 3,550' | 540' | Greene | Lexington |
| 44 | Halcott Mountain | 97 | 3,530' | 720' | Greene | West Kill |
| 45 | Vly Mountain | 98 | 3,529' | 659' | Greene | West Kill |
| 46 | Windham High Peak | 99 | 3,524' | 754' | Greene | Hensonville |
| 47 | Adams, Mount | 100 | 3,520' | 1,043' | Essex | Mount Adams |
| 48 | Rocky Mountain | 3,508' | 218' | Ulster | West Shokan | |
| 49 | Pitchoff Mountain | 102 | 3,497' | 1,152' | Essex | North Elba |
| 50 | Vanderwhacker Mountain | 124 | 3,408' | 1,686' | Essex | Vanderwhacker Mountain |
| 51 | Colonels Chair | 3,210' | 20' | Greene | Hunter | |
| 52 | Overlook Mountain | 175 | 3,150' | 640' | Ulster | Woodstock |