| # | Name | Elevation | Prominence | Isolation | Counties | Quadrangle |
| 1 | Flat Top Mountain | 12,359' | 4,063' | 40.82 | Garfield | Orno Peak |
| 2 | Zirkel, Mount | 12,187' | 3,479' | 38.03 | Jackson & Routt | Mount Zirkel |
| 3 | Orno Peak | 12,139' | 752' | 4.70 | Garfield | Orno Peak |
| 4 | Flattop Mountain | 12,127' | 591' | 2.34 | Jackson & Routt | Mount Zirkel |
| 5 | 11998 | 11,998' | 329' | 2.07 | Garfield | Devils Causeway |
| 6 | Lost Lakes Peaks, East | 11,946' | 406' | 4.06 | Garfield | Devils Causeway |
| 7 | Lost Ranger Peak | 11,938' | 1,203' | 8.14 | Jackson & Routt | Mount Ethel |
| 8 | "Peggy Peak" | 11,938' | 631' | 1.74 | Jackson | Mount Zirkel |
| 9 | Ethel, Mount | 11,931' | 552' | 2.96 | Jackson & Routt | Mount Ethel |
| 10 | Sheep Mountain | 11,826' | 1,794' | 7.16 | Grand & Jackson | Hyannis Peak |
| 11 | 11822 | 11,822' | 834' | 2.21 | Jackson | Mount Zirkel |
| 12 | "Goosenest" | 11,816' | 617' | 1.92 | Jackson & Routt | Mount Zirkel |
| 13 | Dome, The | 11,742' | 483' | 1.78 | Routt | Mount Ethel |
| 14 | "Anvil Horn" | 11,709' | 320' | 1.11 | Jackson | Mount Ethel |
| 15 | 11636 | 11,636' | 309' | 0.89 | Jackson | Mount Zirkel |
| 16 | Bear Mountain | 11,608' | 613' | 1.71 | Jackson | Boettcher Lake |
| 17 | Hyannis Peak | 11,608' | 484' | 2.48 | Jackson | Hyannis Peak |
| 18 | Arapaho Ridge | 11,584' | 300' | 1.90 | Jackson | Buffalo Peak |
| 19 | "Mount Hobbs" | 11,581' | 627' | 1.83 | Routt | Mount Ethel |
| 20 | Red Elephant Mountain | 11,575' | 486' | 1.83 | Jackson | Davis Peak |
| 21 | 11575 | 11,575' | 333' | 0.97 | Grand & Jackson | Hyannis Peak |
| 22 | "The Forehead" | 11,543' | 523' | 1.42 | Jackson | Mount Ethel |
| 23 | Pyramid Peak | 11,540' | 511' | 3.25 | Rio Blanco | Devils Causeway |
| 24 | "Rabbit Ears Divide Peak" | 11,522' | 635' | 1.86 | Grand & Jackson | Hyannis Peak |
| 25 | Little Agnes Mountain | 11,501' | 445' | 1.36 | Routt | Mount Zirkel |
| 26 | Haystack Mountain | 11,497' | 1,061' | 2.81 | Grand & Jackson | Parkview Mountain |
| 27 | 11494 | 11,494' | 368' | 1.50 | Grand & Jackson | Parkview Mountain |
| 28 | Davis Peak | 11,422' | 922' | 3.79 | Jackson | Davis Peak |
| 29 | Poison Ridge | 11,417' | 517' | 1.78 | Grand & Jackson | Parkview Mountain |
| 30 | Buck Mountain, South | 11,396' | 1,576' | 3.02 | Routt | Mount Zirkel |
| 31 | Buck Mountain, North | 11,372' | 392' | 1.51 | Jackson & Routt | Davis Peak |
| 32 | 11227 | 11,227' | 400' | 1.67 | Jackson | Mount Ethel |
| 33 | 11179 | 11,179' | 342' | 2.03 | Jackson & Routt | Mount Ethel |
| 34 | 11174 | 11,174' | 416' | 2.40 | Routt | Buffalo Pass |
| 35 | 11170 | 11,170' | 392' | 2.18 | Routt | Mount Zirkel |
| 36 | 11161 | 11,161' | 421' | 1.23 | Jackson | Mount Ethel |
| 37 | Pagoda Peak | 11,124' | 778' | 8.01 | Rio Blanco | Pagoda Peak |
| 38 | 11107 | 11,107' | 565' | 2.79 | Routt | Orno Peak |
| 39 | 11094 | 11,094' | 345' | 1.57 | Jackson | Davis Peak |
| 40 | 11080 | 11,080' | 330' | 1.25 | Routt | Mount Ethel |
| 41 | 10979 | 10,979' | 570' | 1.97 | Routt | Buffalo Pass |
| 42 | 10955 | 10,955' | 395' | 2.00 | Rio Blanco | Ripple Creek |
| 43 | Buffalo Ridge | 10,939' | 731' | 2.96 | Jackson | Davis Peak |
| 44 | 10889 | 10,889' | 469' | 2.23 | Routt | Mount Zirkel |
| 45 | "McFaddin Peak" | 10,872' | 2,180' | 18.18 | Routt | Meaden Peak |
| 46 | Farwell Mountain | 10,860' | 1,240' | 6.48 | Routt | Farwell Mountain |
| 47 | Sand Peak | 10,855' | 730' | 2.94 | Rio Blanco | Lost Park |
| 48 | Sand Mountain | 10,853' | 465' | 0.83 | Routt | Meaden Peak |
| 49 | Hahns Peak | 10,847' | 1,646' | 4.43 | Routt | Hahns Peak |
| 50 | Black Mountain | 10,846' | 2,428' | 16.37 | Moffat | Buck Point |
| 51 | Shipman Mountain | 10,834' | 959' | 8.85 | Jackson & Larimer | Shipman Mountain |
| 52 | Dirt Benchmark | 10,815' | 1,660' | 18.52 | Grand | Gore Mountain |
| 53 | 10796 | 10,796' | 306' | 0.72 | Routt | Mount Zirkel |
| 54 | Black Mountain | 10,787' | 1,287' | 3.39 | Jackson | West Fork Lake |
| 55 | 10776 | 10,776' | 755' | 2.93 | Routt | Gore Mountain |
| 56 | Elmo Benchmark | 10,696' | 771' | 11.12 | Jackson | Mount Werner |
| 57 | Gore Mountain | 10,687' | 947' | 2.84 | Routt | Gore Mountain |
| 58 | Little Haystack Mountain | 10,681' | 621' | 3.90 | Jackson | Spicer Peak |
| 59 | Oliphant, Mount | 10,670' | 570' | 2.18 | Moffat | Freeman Reservoir |
| 60 | "Rabbit Ears" | 10,662' | 320' | 1.47 | Jackson | Rabbit Ears Peak |
| 61 | Bears Ears Peaks, West | 10,582' | 1,043' | 6.28 | Routt | Bears Ears Peaks |
| 62 | Werner, Mount | 10,574' | 493' | 5.71 | Routt | Mount Werner |
| 63 | 10571 | 10,571' | 300' | 0.85 | Jackson | West Fork Lake |
| 64 | Welba, Mount | 10,569' | 469' | 1.39 | Moffat | Freeman Reservoir |
| 65 | Green Ridge | 10,560' | 1,553' | 7.14 | Routt | Green Ridge |
| 66 | Meaden Peak | 10,559' | 562' | 1.13 | Routt | Meaden Peak |
| 67 | Walton Peak | 10,559' | 1,019' | 6.73 | Routt | Walton Peak |
| 68 | Buck Point | 10,550' | 450' | 0.89 | Moffat | Buck Point |
| 69 | Pass Benchmark | 10,539' | 1,015' | 8.16 | Grand | Gore Pass |
| 70 | Dome Peak | 10,524' | 824' | 3.60 | Routt | Farwell Mountain |
| 71 | 10473 | 10,473' | 318' | 2.36 | Jackson | Davis Peak |
| 72 | Diamond Peak | 10,433' | 770' | 2.49 | Routt | Meaden Peak |
| 73 | Buffalo Mountain | 10,391' | 320' | 3.93 | Routt | Buffalo Pass |
| 74 | 10382 | 10,382' | 867' | 4.70 | Routt | Walton Peak |
| 75 | 10359 | 10,359' | 459' | 2.91 | Jackson & Routt | West Fork Lake |
| 76 | 10357 | 10,357' | 353' | 2.46 | Routt | Rocky Peak |
| 77 | "Cougar Mountain" | 10,329' | 540' | 2.79 | Routt | Buck Point |
| 78 | 10328 | 10,328' | 448' | 2.84 | Routt | Floyd Peak |
| 79 | Nipple Peak | 10,324' | 1,144' | 5.16 | Routt | Meaden Peak |
| 80 | 10296 | 10,296' | 596' | 2.05 | Routt | Walton Peak |
| 81 | 10285 | 10,285' | 454' | 2.73 | Rio Blanco | Ripple Creek |
| 82 | Dunckley Flat Tops (HP) | 10,271' | 646' | 5.99 | Rio Blanco | Dunckley Pass |
| 83 | 10264 | 10,264' | 301' | 1.50 | Moffat | Buck Point |
| 84 | Lone Spring Butte | 10,262' | 301' | 0.90 | Routt | Green Ridge |
| 85 | 10261 | 10,261' | 903' | 2.49 | Routt | Meaden Peak |
| 86 | 10240 | 10,240' | 301' | 2.09 | Routt | Walton Peak |
| 87 | 10157 | 10,157' | 341' | 0.53 | Routt | Meaden Peak |
| 88 | Dennis Hump | 10,155' | 460' | 2.04 | Jackson | Spicer Peak |
| 89 | Sugar Loaf Mountain | 10,112' | 1,094' | 3.36 | Routt | Bears Ears Peaks |
| 90 | 10111 | 10,111' | 305' | 3.05 | Rio Blanco | Dunckley Pass |
| 91 | 10106 | 10,106' | 342' | 0.89 | Rio Blanco | Dunckley Pass |
| 92 | Saddle Mountain | 10,065' | 872' | 2.07 | Routt | Bears Ears Peaks |
| 93 | 10058 | 10,058' | 338' | 2.78 | Jackson | Davis Peak |
| 94 | 10049 | 10,049' | 302' | 1.64 | Routt | Green Ridge |
| 95 | 10020 | 10,020' | 414' | 2.71 | Grand | Gore Pass |
| 96 | 10014 | 10,014' | 835' | 1.59 | Routt | Meaden Peak |
| 97 | Green Ridge | 9,977' | 541' | 3.57 | Jackson | Rand |
| 98 | Shield Mountain | 9,946' | 961' | 3.50 | Routt | Shield Mountain |
| 99 | 9894 | 9,894' | 394' | 3.84 | Routt | Floyd Peak |
| 100 | Burro Mountain | 9,839' | 427' | 3.65 | Rio Blanco | Pagoda Peak |
| 101 | Baker Mountain | 9,824' | 394' | 3.57 | Grand & Jackson | Rabbit Ears Peak |
| 102 | 9806 | 9,806' | 310' | 0.53 | Routt | Meaden Peak |
| 103 | 9789 | 9,789' | 309' | 0.61 | Routt | Meaden Peak |
| 104 | 9765 | 9,765' | 425' | 4.12 | Jackson & Routt | West Fork Lake |
| 105 | Saddle Mountain | 9,736' | 316' | 1.91 | Routt | Pilot Knob |
| 106 | 9731 | 9,731' | 330' | 2.87 | Routt | Mount Werner |
| 107 | 9726 | 9,726' | 516' | 4.02 | Jackson | Pearl |
| 108 | Iron Mountain | 9,725' | 825' | 2.45 | Routt | Hahns Peak |
| 109 | 9722 | 9,722' | 422' | 2.17 | Routt | Walton Peak |
| 110 | 9713 | 9,713' | 301' | 3.51 | Rio Blanco | Sand Point |
| 111 | 9705 | 9,705' | 645' | 4.48 | Routt | Lynx Pass |
| 112 | 9703 | 9,703' | 621' | 1.59 | Routt | Shield Mountain |
| 113 | 9692 | 9,692' | 337' | 3.53 | Rio Blanco | Sleepy Cat Peak |
| 114 | 9676 | 9,676' | 306' | 2.97 | Jackson | Rand |
| 115 | 9675 | 9,675' | 400' | 2.89 | Routt | Lynx Pass |
| 116 | 9669 | 9,669' | 306' | 1.24 | Routt | Shield Mountain |
| 117 | Anthracite Ridge | 9,656' | 598' | 2.46 | Routt | Pilot Knob |
| 118 | 9621 | 9,621' | 361' | 1.63 | Routt | Mount Werner |
| 119 | 9596 | 9,596' | 397' | 0.72 | Routt | Meaden Peak |
| 120 | 9588 | 9,588' | 528' | 1.87 | Routt | Hahns Peak |
| 121 | 9586 | 9,586' | 326' | 2.33 | Grand | Lake Agnes |
| 122 | 9570 | 9,570' | 310' | 0.56 | Routt | Shield Mountain |
| 123 | 9565 | 9,565' | 465' | 2.02 | Routt | Farwell Mountain |
| 124 | Sawtooth Mountain | 9,565' | 425' | 3.00 | Routt | Buck Point |
| 125 | City Mountain | 9,559' | 646' | 1.58 | Routt | Shield Mountain |
| 126 | Elkhorn Mountain | 9,556' | 456' | 2.97 | Routt | Elkhorn Mountain |
| 127 | 9529 | 9,529' | 949' | 1.06 | Routt | Farwell Mountain |
| 128 | 9502 | 9,502' | 309' | 1.67 | Routt | Walton Peak |
| 129 | Little Mountain | 9,492' | 352' | 1.06 | Routt | Hahns Peak |
| 130 | 9420 | 9,420' | 348' | 2.98 | Routt | Lynx Pass |
| 131 | 9342 | 9,342' | 539' | 2.97 | Routt | Floyd Peak |
| 132 | 9338 | 9,338' | 301' | 2.44 | Routt | Lynx Pass |
| 133 | Quaker Mountain | 9,330' | 726' | 3.39 | Routt | Quaker Mountain |
| 134 | 9315 | 9,315' | 379' | 1.66 | Rio Blanco | Sand Point |
| 135 | Grouse Mountain | 9,281' | 901' | 2.00 | Routt | Hahns Peak |
| 136 | Pinkham Mountain | 9,270' | 640' | 8.33 | Jackson | Kings Canyon |
| 137 | Rocky Peak | 9,258' | 388' | 3.92 | Routt | Rocky Peak |
| 138 | 9218 | 9,218' | 518' | 1.18 | Routt | Hahns Peak |
| 139 | Picket Mountain | 9,212' | 512' | 1.20 | Routt | Pilot Knob |
| 140 | 9180 | 9,180' | 520' | 1.03 | Routt | Rocky Peak |
| 141 | McAlpin Mountain | 9,180' | 535' | 1.66 | Routt | Clark |
| 142 | 9125 | 9,125' | 345' | 1.81 | Routt | Lynx Pass |
| 143 | 9106 | 9,106' | 395' | 1.27 | Routt | Bears Ears Peaks |
| 144 | 9100 | 9,100' | 706' | 3.11 | Routt | Floyd Peak |
| 145 | Baldy Peak | 9,100' | 360' | 2.85 | Routt | Quaker Mountain |
| 146 | 9087 | 9,087' | 347' | 2.47 | Routt | Farwell Mountain |
| 147 | Hog Park Benchmark | 9,078' | 378' | 3.72 | Jackson | Dudley Creek |
| 148 | 9070 | 9,070' | 770' | 2.11 | Routt | Farwell Mountain |
| 149 | 9061 | 9,061' | 481' | 1.50 | Jackson | West Fork Lake |
| 150 | 9005 | 9,005' | 305' | 0.74 | Routt | Pilot Knob |
| 151 | 8992 | 8,992' | 412' | 1.87 | Routt | Shield Mountain |
| 152 | 8940 | 8,940' | 520' | 3.61 | Routt | Floyd Peak |
| 153 | Lester Mountain | 8,861' | 781' | 1.94 | Routt | Hahns Peak |
| 154 | 8850 | 8,850' | 312' | 1.43 | Routt | Meaden Peak |
| 155 | 8767 | 8,767' | 347' | 3.88 | Routt | Elkhorn Mountain |
| 156 | 8752 | 8,752' | 310' | 1.03 | Routt | Shield Mountain |
| 157 | 8610 | 8,610' | 390' | 1.35 | Routt | Shield Mountain |
| 158 | Copper Ridge | 8,436' | 576' | 2.29 | Routt | Rocky Peak |
| 159 | 8392 | 8,392' | 379' | 1.96 | Routt | Clark |
| 160 | 8336 | 8,336' | 383' | 2.74 | Jackson | Northgate |
| 161 | 8149 | 8,149' | 312' | 1.03 | Routt | Rocky Peak |