| Name | Elevation | Prominence | Counties | Quadrangle | Distance (mi.) |
| 1837 | 1,837' | 412' | Chautauqua | Clymer | 1497.54 |
| 1865 | 1,865' | 300' | Chautauqua | Clymer | 1503.13 |
| Clymer Hill | 1,875' | 330' | Chautauqua | North Clymer | 1504.42 |
| 2052 | 2,052' | 337' | Chautauqua | Hamlet | 1526.45 |
| 2125 | 2,125' | 795' | Chautauqua | Hamlet | 1527.43 |
| 2170 | 2,170' | 580' | Cattaraugus | Ivory | 1533.18 |
| 2210 | 2,210' | 660' | Cattaraugus | Steamburg | 1539.99 |
| Parker Hill | 2,324' | 394' | Cattaraugus | Little Valley | 1542.88 |
| 2390 | 2,390' | 360' | Cattaraugus | Little Valley | 1544.15 |
| Shutts Hill | 2,410' | 920' | Cattaraugus | Little Valley | 1544.74 |
| Clare Benchmark | 2,430' | 340' | Cattaraugus | Knapp Creek | 1559.58 |
| 2464 | 2,464' | 330' | Allegany | Bolivar | 1580.63 |
| White Hill | 2,515' | 505' | Allegany | Allentown | 1583.83 |
| Alma Hill | 2,548' | 958' | Allegany | Allentown | 1586.68 |
| Crawford Benchmark | 2,590' | 680' | Delaware | Corbett | 1736.00 |
| Cherry Ridge | 2,628' | 398' | Delaware | Downsville | 1743.40 |
| Ice Cave Mountain | 2,680' | 525' | Herkimer | Honnedaga Lake | 1745.61 |
| 2725 | 2,725' | 475' | Delaware | Downsville | 1745.71 |
| Brock Mountain | 2,770' | 680' | Delaware | Downsville | 1746.63 |
| Bramley Mountain | 2,817' | 707' | Delaware | Bloomville | 1749.81 |
| 2942 | 2,942' | 712' | Delaware | Lewbeach | 1750.61 |
| Middle Mountain | 2,975' | 685' | Delaware | Lewbeach | 1751.84 |
| West Canada Mountain | 3,001' | 669' | Hamilton | Spruce Lake Mountain | 1752.73 |
| Pisgah, Mount | 3,345' | 895' | Delaware | Margaretville | 1754.25 |
| "North Plattekill Mountain" | 3,350' | 1,780' | Delaware | Hobart | 1757.74 |
| Mill Brook Ridge | 3,490' | 380' | Ulster | Arena | 1760.11 |
| Little Moose Mountain | 3,631' | 1,220' | Hamilton | Wakely Mountain | 1760.55 |