| # | Name | Rank | Elevation | Prominence | Counties | Quadrangle |
| 1 | Humphreys Peak | 1 | 12,634' | 6,054' | Coconino | Humphreys Peak |
| 2 | Graham, Mount | 10 | 10,709' | 6,313' | Graham | Mount Graham |
| 3 | Kendrick Peak | 12 | 10,418' | 2,488' | Coconino | Kendrick Peak |
| 4 | Chiricahua Peak | 25 | 9,776' | 5,163' | Cochise | Chiricahua Peak |
| 5 | Flys Peak | 28 | 9,667' | 420' | Cochise | Chiricahua Peak |
| 6 | Miller Peak | 46 | 9,468' | 5,007' | Cochise | Miller Peak |
| 7 | Wrightson, Mount | 49 | 9,453' | 4,591' | Santa Cruz | Mount Wrightson |
| 8 | Bill Williams Mountain | 70 | 9,256' | 2,306' | Coconino | Williams South |
| 9 | Carr Peak | 77 | 9,237' | 700' | Cochise | Miller Peak |
| 10 | Kaibab Plateau | 78 | 9,220' | 3,610' | Coconino | De Motte Park |
| 11 | Lemmon, Mount | 90 | 9,166' | 5,164' | Pima | Mount Lemmon |
| 12 | "Mount Ian" | 92 | 9,146' | 366' | Santa Cruz | Mount Wrightson |
| 13 | Saddle Mountain | 126 | 8,880' | 1,010' | Coconino | White Horse Hills |
| 14 | Hualapai Peak | 185 | 8,417' | 4,447' | Mohave | Hualapai Peak |
| 15 | Hayden Peak | 189 | 8,390' | 370' | Mohave | Hualapai Peak |