| # | Name | Rank | Elevation | Prominence | Counties | Quadrangle |
| 1 | Borah Peak | 1 | 12,666' | 5,996' | Custer | Borah Peak |
| 2 | "Mount Church" | 3 | 12,220' | 960' | Custer | Leatherman Peak |
| 3 | Diamond Peak | 4 | 12,200' | 5,374' | Butte | Diamond Peak |
| 4 | Donaldson Peak | 8 | 12,023' | 323' | Custer | Leatherman Peak |
| 5 | Old Hyndman Peak | 28 | 11,775' | 955' | Blaine & Custer | Grays Peak |
| 6 | Galena Peak | 94 | 11,167' | 742' | Blaine & Custer | Galena Peak |