| # | Name | Rank | Elevation | Prominence | Counties | Quadrangle |
| 1 | Humphreys Peak | 1 | 12,634' | 6,054' | Coconino | Humphreys Peak |
| 2 | Trumbull, Mount | 254 | 8,029' | 2,974' | Mohave | Mount Trumbull |
| 3 | Baboquivari Peak | 363 | 7,734' | 4,204' | Pima | Baboquivari Peak |
| 4 | Old Caves Crater | 672 | 7,183' | 443' | Coconino | Sunset Crater West |
| 5 | Tipton, Mount | 693 | 7,148' | 3,638' | Mohave | Mount Tipton |