| # | Name | Rank | Elevation | Prominence | Counties | Quadrangle |
| 1 | Castle Peak | 10 | 14,274' | 2,358' | Gunnison & Pitkin | Hayden Peak |
| 2 | Quandary Peak | 11 | 14,272' | 1,134' | Summit | Breckenridge |
| 3 | Wetterhorn Peak | 49 | 14,021' | 1,656' | Hinsdale & Ouray | Wetterhorn Peak |
| 4 | Wilson Peak | 50 | 14,021' | 865' | San Miguel | Mount Wilson |
| 5 | Matterhorn Peak | 195 | 13,590' | 545' | Hinsdale | Uncompahgre Peak |