| # | Name | Rank | Elevation | Prominence | Counties | Quadrangle |
| 1 | Hawksbill | 87 | 4,050' | 2,148' | Madison & Page | Big Meadows |
| 2 | Stony Man | 97 | 4,011' | 671' | Madison & Page | Old Rag Mountain |
| 3 | Blackrock | 156 | 3,740' | 480' | Madison & Page | Big Meadows |
| 4 | Pinnacle, The | 160 | 3,730' | 670' | Page & Rappahannock | Thornton Gap |
| 5 | Bettys Rock | 171 | 3,700' | 339' | Madison & Page | Big Meadows |
| 6 | 3620 | 197 | 3,620' | 480' | Greene & Rockingham | Elkton East |
| 7 | Bearfence Mountain | 208 | 3,580' | 360' | Greene & Page | Fletcher |
| 8 | Big Flat Mountain | 278 | 3,389' | 1,129' | Albemarle & Rockingham | Browns Cove |
| 9 | Old Rag Mountain | 324 | 3,291' | 1,391' | Madison | Old Rag Mountain |
| 10 | 3100 | 425 | 3,100' | 360' | Albemarle, Greene, & Rockingham | McGaheysville |
| 11 | Pass Mountain | 459 | 3,052' | 632' | Page & Rappahannock | Thornton Gap |
| 12 | 2860 | 593 | 2,860' | 360' | Page & Rappahannock | Thornton Gap |