| # | Name | Rank | Elevation | Prominence | Counties | Quadrangle |
| 1 | Black Elk Peak | 1 | 7,242' | 2,932' | Pennington | Custer |
| 2 | Little Devils Tower | 7 | 6,982' | 428' | Custer | Custer |
| 3 | 6181 | 40 | 6,181' | 401' | Custer | Berne |
| 4 | Custer Mountain | 46 | 6,100' | 600' | Custer | Custer |
| 5 | 6060 | 48 | 6,060' | 400' | Custer | Cicero Peak |
| 6 | Coolidge, Mount | 54 | 6,023' | 683' | Custer | Mount Coolidge |
| 7 | 5900 | 61 | 5,900' | 560' | Custer | Iron Mountain |
| 8 | 5834 | 73 | 5,834' | 334' | Custer | Cicero Peak |
| 9 | 5778 | 80 | 5,778' | 398' | Custer | Custer |