| # | Name | Rank | Elevation | Prominence | Counties | Quadrangle |
| 1 | Rogers, Mount | 1 | 5,712' | 2,461' | Grayson & Smyth | Whitetop Mountain |
| 2 | Hawksbill | 87 | 4,050' | 2,148' | Madison & Page | Big Meadows |
| 3 | Stony Man | 97 | 4,011' | 671' | Madison & Page | Old Rag Mountain |
| 4 | Flat Top Mountain | 98 | 3,994' | 1,484' | Bedford & Botetourt | Peaks of Otter |
| 5 | Sharp Top Mountain | 119 | 3,862' | 1,272' | Bedford | Peaks of Otter |