| # | Name | Rank | Elevation | Prominence | Counties | Quadrangle |
| 1 | Black Elk Peak | 1 | 7,242' | 2,932' | Pennington | Custer |
| 2 | Odakota Mountain | 2 | 7,199' | 1,327' | Pennington | Ditch Creek |
| 3 | Bear Mountain | 3 | 7,168' | 457' | Pennington | Berne |
| 4 | Terry Peak | 5 | 7,070' | 1,012' | Lawrence | Lead |
| 5 | "Sylvan Peak" | 6 | 7,001' | 769' | Custer | Custer |
| 6 | Little Devils Tower | 7 | 6,982' | 428' | Custer | Custer |
| 7 | Custer Peak | 14 | 6,804' | 654' | Lawrence | Minnesota Ridge |
| 8 | Castle Peak | 30 | 6,358' | 448' | Pennington | Rochford |
| 9 | Cicero Peak | 43 | 6,166' | 503' | Custer | Cicero Peak |
| 10 | Coolidge, Mount | 54 | 6,023' | 683' | Custer | Mount Coolidge |
| 11 | Scruton Mountain | 60 | 5,922' | 342' | Pennington | Silver City |
| 12 | Crow Peak | 81 | 5,771' | 911' | Lawrence | Maurice |
| 13 | Bishop Mountain | 87 | 5,706' | 326' | Pennington | Hill City |
| 14 | Theodore Roosevelt, Mount | 89 | 5,700' | 360' | Lawrence | Spearfish |
| 15 | Elk Mountains (HP) | 93 | 5,669' | 839' | Custer | Clifton |