| # | Name | Rank | Elevation | Prominence | Counties | Quadrangle |
| 1 | Big Mountain | 58 | 2,458' | 1,448' | Franklin & Fulton | McConnellsburg |
| 2 | Blue Mountain | 148 | 2,270' | 640' | Cumberland & Perry | Newburg |
| 3 | Shade Mountain | 183 | 2,228' | 1,218' | Juniata | Lewistown |
| 4 | Shade Mountain | 226 | 2,189' | 1,450' | Snyder | Beaver Springs |