| # | Name | Rank | Elevation | Prominence | Counties | Quadrangle |
| 1 | Brushy Mountain | 1428 | 7,620' | 2,332' | Grant | Crookson Peak |
| 2 | West Malpais Wilderness HP | 7,615' | 50' | Cibola | Cerro Brilliante | |
| 3 | Timber Mountain | 1472 | 7,565' | 2,820' | Sierra | Apache Gap |
| 4 | Eddy County HP | 1525 | 7,500' | 400' | Eddy | El Paso Gap |
| 5 | Caja del Rio Plateau | 1542 | 7,472' | 1,045' | Santa Fe | Montoso Peak |
| 6 | Florida Peak | 7,446' | 206' | Luna | Gym Peak | |
| 7 | Inscription Rock | 7,430' | 80' | Cibola | El Morro | |
| 8 | Camp Wilderness Ridge | 1578 | 7,420' | 600' | Eddy | El Paso Gap |
| 9 | Brushy Mountain | 1587 | 7,405' | 1,185' | Catron | Glenwood |
| 10 | Brushy Mountain | 1596 | 7,387' | 1,047' | Sierra | Sugarloaf Peak |
| 11 | Wind Mountain | 1670 | 7,280' | 2,350' | Otero | Cornudas Mountain |
| 12 | One Tree Peak | 1810 | 7,089' | 669' | Chaves | Chimney Lake |