| # | Name | Rank | Elevation | Prominence | Counties | Quadrangle |
| 1 | Organ Peak | 549 | 8,872' | 1,022' | Doña Ana | Organ Peak |
| 2 | Sierra Grande | 638 | 8,720' | 1,910' | Union | Capulin |
| 3 | Cookes Peak | 827 | 8,408' | 2,588' | Luna | OK Canyon |
| 4 | Big Hatchet Peak | 852 | 8,356' | 3,706' | Hidalgo | Big Hatchet Peak |
| 5 | Capulin Mountain | 981 | 8,182' | 1,012' | Union | Folsom |