| # | Name | Rank | Elevation | Prominence | Counties | Quadrangle |
| 1 | Sierra Blanca Peak | 39 | 11,977' | 5,544' | Otero | Sierra Blanca Peak |
| 2 | Elk Mountain | 50 | 11,661' | 601' | San Miguel | Elk Mountain |
| 3 | Lookout Mountain | 52 | 11,573' | 407' | Lincoln | Nogal Peak |
| 4 | Taylor, Mount | 63 | 11,301' | 4,094' | Cibola | Mount Taylor |
| 5 | Redondo Peak | 67 | 11,254' | 2,474' | Sandoval | Redondo Peak |