| # | Name | Rank | Elevation | Prominence | Counties | Quadrangle |
| 1 | 5948 | 58 | 5,948' | 568' | Custer | Cicero Peak |
| 2 | Scruton Mountain | 60 | 5,922' | 342' | Pennington | Silver City |
| 3 | 5900 | 61 | 5,900' | 560' | Custer | Iron Mountain |
| 4 | 5834 | 73 | 5,834' | 334' | Custer | Cicero Peak |
| 5 | Theodore Roosevelt, Mount | 89 | 5,700' | 360' | Lawrence | Spearfish |
| 6 | 5688 | 92 | 5,688' | 388' | Custer | Iron Mountain |
| 7 | 5604 | 100 | 5,604' | 384' | Custer | Cicero Peak |
| 8 | Meade County HP | 5,470' | 180' | Meade | Deadman Mountain | |
| 9 | 5460 | 110 | 5,460' | 400' | Custer | Iron Mountain |
| 10 | 5460 | 111 | 5,460' | 360' | Custer | Iron Mountain |
| 11 | 5438 | 114 | 5,438' | 548' | Meade | Deadman Mountain |
| 12 | Silver Mountain | 118 | 5,405' | 425' | Pennington | Mount Rushmore |
| 13 | 5380 | 120 | 5,380' | 320' | Custer | Fourmile |
| 14 | 5380 | 122 | 5,380' | 320' | Custer | Iron Mountain |
| 15 | "Veteran's Peak" | 124 | 5,333' | 343' | Meade | Deadman Mountain |
| 16 | Boulder Hill | 125 | 5,331' | 391' | Pennington | Mount Rushmore |
| 17 | 5316 | 128 | 5,316' | 466' | Custer | Pringle |
| 18 | 5250 | 133 | 5,250' | 320' | Custer | Pringle |
| 19 | 5110 | 145 | 5,110' | 400' | Meade | Deadman Mountain |
| 20 | 5110 | 146 | 5,110' | 300' | Meade | Deadman Mountain |
| 21 | 5048 | 148 | 5,048' | 348' | Pennington | Mount Rushmore |
| 22 | Rankin Ridge | 150 | 5,013' | 403' | Custer | Mount Coolidge |