| # | Name | Rank | Elevation | Prominence | Counties | Quadrangle |
| 1 | Red Hill | 222 | 2,990' | 600' | Ulster | Claryville |
| 2 | Saint Regis Mountain | 281 | 2,874' | 1,242' | Franklin | Saint Regis Mountain |
| 3 | Berlin Mountain | 309 | 2,818' | 1,568' | Rensselaer | Berlin |
| 4 | Owls Head Mountain | 312 | 2,811' | 1,010' | Hamilton | Deerland |
| 5 | Marble Mountain | 2,752' | 46' | Essex | Wilmington | |
| 6 | Tremper Mountain | 361 | 2,730' | 340' | Ulster | Phoenicia |
| 7 | Goodnow Mountain | 385 | 2,690' | 1,027' | Essex | Newcomb |
| 8 | Black Mountain | 406 | 2,650' | 2,300' | Washington | Shelving Rock |
| 9 | Leonard Hill | 2,630' | 120' | Schoharie | Livingstonville | |
| 10 | Sawyer Mountain | 428 | 2,627' | 807' | Hamilton | Burgess Mountain |
| 11 | Raimer, Mount | 468 | 2,570' | 360' | Rensselaer | Berlin |
| 12 | Pharaoh Mountain | 475 | 2,556' | 1,606' | Essex | Pharaoh Mountain |
| 13 | Arab Mountain | 481 | 2,549' | 866' | Saint Lawrence | Pierce Field |
| 14 | Ticetonyk Mountain | 514 | 2,510' | 1,640' | Ulster | Bearsville |
| 15 | Azure Mountain | 515 | 2,510' | 1,000' | Franklin | Lake Ozonia |
| 16 | Woodhull Mountain | 707 | 2,365' | 466' | Herkimer | Bisby Lakes |
| 17 | Bald Mountain | 2,349' | 214' | Herkimer | Old Forge | |
| 18 | Petersburg Mountain | 753 | 2,330' | 500' | Schoharie | Cobleskill |
| 19 | Hooker Mountain | 755 | 2,330' | 440' | Otsego | Schenevus |
| 20 | Brace Mountain | 2,317' | 197' | Dutchess | Bash Bish Falls | |
| 21 | Shawangunk Mountains (HP) | 821 | 2,289' | 1,739' | Ulster | Napanoch |
| 22 | Stillwater Mountain | 855 | 2,267' | 407' | Herkimer | Stillwater Mountain |
| 23 | Pokamoonshine Mountain | 959 | 2,181' | 361' | Essex | Clintonville |
| 24 | Gomer Hill | 1052 | 2,115' | 985' | Lewis | Glenfield |
| 25 | Meenahga Mountain | 1097 | 2,083' | 393' | Franklin | Gabriels |
| 26 | Harvey Mountain | 1115 | 2,062' | 995' | Berkshire & Columbia | State Line |
| 27 | Spruce Mountain | 2,009' | 99' | Saratoga | Porter Corners |