| # | Name | Rank | Elevation | Prominence | Counties | Quadrangle |
| 1 | High Point | 1 | 1,799' | 868' | Sussex | Port Jervis South |
| 2 | Sunrise Mountain | 2 | 1,653' | 363' | Sussex | Branchville |
| 3 | Catfish Benchmark | 5 | 1,570' | 320' | Warren | Flatbrookville |
| 4 | Tammany, Mount | 1,550' | 40' | Warren | Portland | |
| 5 | Fox Hill | 32 | 1,035' | 305' | Hunterdon | Califon |