| # | Name | Rank | Elevation | Prominence | Counties | Quadrangle |
| 1 | 9970 | 227 | 9,970' | 400' | Los Alamos | Valle Toledo |
| 2 | Teepee Peak | 9,957' | 57' | Socorro | Blue Mountain | |
| 3 | Bearwallow Mountain | 231 | 9,953' | 1,426' | Catron | Bearwallow Mountain |
| 4 | Corner Mountain | 235 | 9,938' | 638' | Catron | Bearwallow Mountain |
| 5 | 9900 | 247 | 9,900' | 328' | Lincoln | Capitan Pass |
| 6 | 9870 | 251 | 9,870' | 320' | Los Alamos | Valle Toledo |
| 7 | Cerro Pedernal | 252 | 9,862' | 1,352' | Rio Arriba | Youngsville |
| 8 | 9861 | 254 | 9,861' | 313' | Catron | Bearwallow Mountain |
| 9 | Escondido Mountain | 257 | 9,854' | 1,809' | Catron | Escondido Mountains |
| 10 | Nacimiento Peak | S | 9,801' | 291' | Rio Arriba | Nacimiento Peak |
| 11 | Elk Mountain | 268 | 9,799' | 1,809' | Catron | Pitchfork Canyon |
| 12 | Eagle Peak | 272 | 9,786' | 2,286' | Catron | Eagle Peak |
| 13 | Holt Mountain | 276 | 9,780' | 1,320' | Catron | Holt Mountain |
| 14 | Benson Ridge | 290 | 9,700' | 2,109' | Otero | Sacramento Peak |
| 15 | Buzzard Peak | 294 | 9,700' | 360' | Catron | Eagle Peak |
| 16 | Mangas Mountain | 296 | 9,695' | 1,435' | Catron | Mangas Mountain |
| 17 | 9695 | 297 | 9,695' | 715' | Otero | Sacramento Peak |
| 18 | Spring Mountain | 298 | 9,683' | 583' | Catron | Bearwallow Mountain |
| 19 | Sawyers Peak | 301 | 9,660' | 1,494' | Grant | Hillsboro Peak |
| 20 | Cathey Peak | 9,645' | 265' | Otero | Sacramento Peak | |
| 21 | 9643 | 305 | 9,643' | 343' | Catron | Escondido Mountains |
| 22 | Padilla Point | 9,627' | 167' | Lincoln | Capitan Pass | |
| 23 | Carrizo Peak | 311 | 9,626' | 2,633' | Lincoln | White Oaks South |
| 24 | Cross-O Mountain | 312 | 9,620' | 480' | Grant & Sierra | Hillsboro Peak |
| 25 | Bosque Peak | 317 | 9,610' | 1,390' | Torrance | Bosque Peak |
| 26 | Eureka Mesa | 322 | 9,592' | 342' | Rio Arriba | Nacimiento Peak |
| 27 | Madre Mountain | 326 | 9,567' | 1,988' | Catron | Madre Mountain |
| 28 | Luera Peak | 337 | 9,482' | 1,782' | Catron | Luera Mountains West |
| 29 | Cerro de la Olla | 339 | 9,475' | 1,730' | Taos | Cerro de la Olla |
| 30 | San Miguel Mountain | 341 | 9,473' | 853' | Sandoval | San Miguel Mountain |
| 31 | Crosby Mountains (HP) | 343 | 9,463' | 1,363' | Catron | Crosby Springs |
| 32 | Turner Peak | 345 | 9,455' | 1,105' | Catron | Escudilla Mountain |
| 33 | Horse Peak | 346 | 9,450' | 1,620' | Catron | Horse Mountain West |
| 34 | O Bar O Mountain | 355 | 9,417' | 1,757' | Catron | O Bar O Canyon West |
| 35 | 9403 | 358 | 9,403' | 983' | Catron | Collins Park |
| 36 | 9390 | 361 | 9,390' | 340' | Socorro | Monica Saddle |
| 37 | Beautiful Mountain | 362 | 9,388' | 1,528' | San Juan | Sanostee West |
| 38 | Fox Mountain | 364 | 9,383' | 1,203' | Catron | Gallo Mountains West |
| 39 | 9380 | 365 | 9,380' | 600' | Catron | O Bar O Canyon West |
| 40 | Cerro Pelon | 373 | 9,367' | 1,117' | Rio Arriba | Polvadera Peak |
| 41 | 9361 | 374 | 9,361' | 421' | Catron | Bearwallow Mountain |
| 42 | Davenport Lookout | 376 | 9,354' | 414' | Catron | Madre Mountain |
| 43 | 9348 | 377 | 9,348' | 431' | Grant & Sierra | Hillsboro Peak |
| 44 | 9342 | 378 | 9,342' | 362' | Socorro | Vicks Peak |
| 45 | 9340 | 382 | 9,340' | 360' | Grant | Hillsboro Peak |
| 46 | 9334 | 384 | 9,334' | 611' | Catron | Underwood Lake |
| 47 | Sawtooth Mountains (HP) | 392 | 9,298' | 886' | Catron | Madre Mountain |
| 48 | Black Mountain | 397 | 9,287' | 1,387' | Catron | Black Mountain |
| 49 | 9279 | 400 | 9,279' | 459' | Catron | Eagle Peak |
| 50 | Jim Smith Peak | 9,278' | 98' | Catron | Underwood Lake | |
| 51 | Sacramento Peak | 9,260' | 120' | Otero | Sacramento Peak | |
| 52 | Alamo Peak | 9,260' | 80' | Otero | Sacramento Peak | |
| 53 | Sedgwick, Mount | 408 | 9,256' | 1,866' | Cibola | Mount Sedgwick |
| 54 | 9256 | 409 | 9,256' | 396' | Catron | O Bar O Canyon West |
| 55 | Gallo Peak | 410 | 9,255' | 875' | Catron | Gallo Mountains West |
| 56 | 9245 | 412 | 9,245' | 385' | Catron | John Kerr Peak |
| 57 | 9243 | 414 | 9,243' | 343' | Catron | Collins Park |
| 58 | 9218 | 421 | 9,218' | 318' | Catron | Black Mountain |
| 59 | Pelona Mountain | 422 | 9,212' | 1,312' | Catron | Pelona Mountain |
| 60 | Ladrones Benchmark | 424 | 9,210' | 3,140' | Socorro | Ladron Peak |
| 61 | Capulin Peak | 425 | 9,205' | 1,324' | Rio Arriba | Gallina |
| 62 | 9180 | 434 | 9,180' | 360' | Lincoln | White Oaks South |
| 63 | Cerros de Alejandro, South | 439 | 9,166' | 616' | McKinley | El Dado Mesa |
| 64 | Jones Peak | 444 | 9,147' | 487' | Catron | Underwood Lake |
| 65 | South Crosby Peak | 9,095' | 225' | Catron | Sugarloaf Mountain | |
| 66 | "South Luera" | 472 | 9,060' | 520' | Catron | Luera Mountains East |
| 67 | Jerky Mountains (HP) | 482 | 9,033' | 693' | Catron | Lilley Mountain |
| 68 | Black Peak | 484 | 9,029' | 2,369' | Grant | Twin Sisters |
| 69 | Organ Needle | 489 | 9,021' | 3,778' | Doña Ana | Organ Peak |
| 70 | Black Peak | 491 | 9,010' | 895' | Catron | Black Peak |