| # | Name | Rank | Elevation | Prominence | Counties | Quadrangle |
| 1 | Granite Gap Mountain | 3170 | 4,930' | 500' | Hidalgo | Cotton City |
| 2 | Tortugas Mountain | 3171 | 4,928' | 602' | Doña Ana | Tortugas Mountain |
| 3 | 4815 | 3200 | 4,815' | 471' | Doña Ana | Dona Ana |
| 4 | Wildcat Hill | 4,432' | 97' | Hidalgo | Lordsburg |