| # | Name | Rank | Elevation | Prominence | Counties | Quadrangle |
| 1 | Warren County HP | 3 | 1,610' | 700' | Warren | Portland |
| 2 | Catfish Benchmark | 5 | 1,570' | 320' | Warren | Flatbrookville |
| 3 | Bearfort Mountain | 7 | 1,490' | 340' | Passaic | Wawayanda |
| 4 | Morris County HP | 1,395' | 225' | Morris | Franklin | |
| 5 | Bowling Green Mountain | 1,390' | 220' | Morris | Franklin | |
| 6 | Allamuchy Mountain | 13 | 1,250' | 460' | Warren | Tranquility |
| 7 | Jenny Jump Mountain | 25 | 1,134' | 384' | Warren | Blairstown |
| 8 | 1070 | 28 | 1,070' | 440' | Warren | Belvidere |
| 9 | 1030 | 33 | 1,030' | 340' | Warren | Washington |