| # | Name | Rank | Elevation | Prominence | Counties | Quadrangle |
| 1 | 9965 | 228 | 9,965' | 305' | Socorro | Mount Withington |
| 2 | Nogal Peak | 230 | 9,957' | 1,197' | Lincoln | Nogal Peak |
| 3 | 9878 | 250 | 9,878' | 338' | Socorro | Vicks Peak |
| 4 | Cerro Pedernal | 252 | 9,862' | 1,352' | Rio Arriba | Youngsville |
| 5 | Escondido Mountain | 257 | 9,854' | 1,809' | Catron | Escondido Mountains |
| 6 | 9794 | 270 | 9,794' | 574' | Taos | Tres Ritos |
| 7 | Eagle Peak | 272 | 9,786' | 2,286' | Catron | Eagle Peak |
| 8 | Johnson Mesa | 284 | 9,722' | 582' | San Miguel | El Porvenir |
| 9 | Benson Ridge | 290 | 9,700' | 2,109' | Otero | Sacramento Peak |
| 10 | 9700 | 293 | 9,700' | 360' | Catron | Alegres Mountain |
| 11 | Buzzard Peak | 294 | 9,700' | 360' | Catron | Eagle Peak |
| 12 | 9695 | 297 | 9,695' | 715' | Otero | Sacramento Peak |
| 13 | Cathey Peak | 9,645' | 265' | Otero | Sacramento Peak | |
| 14 | 9643 | 305 | 9,643' | 343' | Catron | Escondido Mountains |
| 15 | Monjeau Peak | 306 | 9,641' | 541' | Lincoln | Angus |
| 16 | Padilla Point | 9,627' | 167' | Lincoln | Capitan Pass | |
| 17 | Carrizo Peak | 311 | 9,626' | 2,633' | Lincoln | White Oaks South |
| 18 | Bosque Peak | 317 | 9,610' | 1,390' | Torrance | Bosque Peak |
| 19 | Madre Mountain | 326 | 9,567' | 1,988' | Catron | Madre Mountain |
| 20 | Cerro de la Olla | 339 | 9,475' | 1,730' | Taos | Cerro de la Olla |
| 21 | Bighorn Peak | 348 | 9,442' | 452' | Rio Arriba | Bighorn Peak |
| 22 | 9420 | 353 | 9,420' | 560' | Santa Fe | McClure Reservoir |
| 23 | 9420 | 354 | 9,420' | 400' | Otero | Sacramento Peak |
| 24 | 9390 | 361 | 9,390' | 340' | Socorro | Monica Saddle |
| 25 | Beautiful Mountain | 362 | 9,388' | 1,528' | San Juan | Sanostee West |
| 26 | Capilla Peak | 372 | 9,368' | 628' | Torrance | Capilla Peak |
| 27 | Davenport Lookout | 376 | 9,354' | 414' | Catron | Madre Mountain |
| 28 | 9342 | 378 | 9,342' | 362' | Socorro | Vicks Peak |
| 29 | 9300 | 390 | 9,300' | 389' | Colfax | Touch-Me-Not Mountain |
| 30 | Los Cerritos de la Cruz, North | 407 | 9,257' | 347' | Rio Arriba | San Antonio Mountain |
| 31 | Sedgwick, Mount | 408 | 9,256' | 1,866' | Cibola | Mount Sedgwick |
| 32 | Ladrones Benchmark | 424 | 9,210' | 3,140' | Socorro | Ladron Peak |
| 33 | 9180 | 431 | 9,180' | 520' | Otero | Cloudcroft |
| 34 | Ladron Peak | 445 | 9,141' | 401' | Socorro | Ladron Peak |
| 35 | Atalaya Mountain | 456 | 9,121' | 741' | Santa Fe | Santa Fe |
| 36 | 9060 | 473 | 9,060' | 320' | Otero | Cloudcroft |
| 37 | Mesa Gurule | 475 | 9,054' | 426' | Rio Arriba | Gallina |
| 38 | Black Peak | 484 | 9,029' | 2,369' | Grant | Twin Sisters |
| 39 | Cerro del Aire | 488 | 9,023' | 713' | Taos | Tres Piedras |
| 40 | Organ Needle | 489 | 9,021' | 3,778' | Doña Ana | Organ Peak |