| # | Name | Rank | Elevation | Prominence | Counties | Quadrangle |
| 1 | Tiffany Peak | 4133 | 6,992' | 602' | La Plata | Tiffany |
| 2 | 6990 | 4136 | 6,990' | 320' | Moffat | Sunbeam |
| 3 | 6980 | 4139 | 6,980' | 400' | Garfield | New Castle |
| 4 | 6961 | 4145 | 6,961' | 341' | Mesa | Payne Wash |
| 5 | 6960 | 4146 | 6,960' | 1,142' | Montrose | Davis Mesa |
| 6 | Line Benchmark | 4154 | 6,935' | 405' | La Plata | Long Mountain |
| 7 | 6910 | 4158 | 6,910' | 320' | La Plata | Bondad Hill |
| 8 | Mesa de Maya | 4166 | 6,897' | 989' | Las Animas | Pine Canyon |
| 9 | Sawtooth Ridge | 4175 | 6,856' | 386' | Montrose | Uravan |
| 10 | Bitter Benchmark | 4178 | 6,848' | 478' | Montrose | Uravan |
| 11 | Warm Springs Cliff | 4184 | 6,824' | 1,135' | Moffat | Canyon of Lodore South |
| 12 | 6805 | 4188 | 6,805' | 425' | Garfield | New Castle |
| 13 | Garfield, Mount | 4195 | 6,777' | 443' | Mesa | Clifton |
| 14 | 6733 | 4202 | 6,733' | 506' | Mesa | Ruby Lee Reservoir |
| 15 | 6730 | 6,730' | 294' | Montrose | Uravan | |
| 16 | Lone Mountain | 4203 | 6,727' | 675' | Moffat | Lone Mountain |
| 17 | 6693 | 4218 | 6,693' | 300' | Rio Blanco | Texas Mountain |
| 18 | 6692 | 4219 | 6,692' | 407' | Moffat | Maybell |
| 19 | 6690 | 6,690' | 204' | Moffat | Maybell | |
| 20 | Cinder Butte | 4225 | 6,670' | 400' | La Plata | Pinkerton Mesa |
| 21 | Black Mountain | 4240 | 6,596' | 1,056' | Mesa | Mesa |
| 22 | 6543 | 6,543' | 289' | Moffat | Lay | |
| 23 | Haystack 3 Point Benchmark | 4264 | 6,500' | 328' | Mesa | Island Mesa |
| 24 | 6460 | 4274 | 6,460' | 440' | Mesa | Juniata Reservoir |
| 25 | "Bison Butte" | 6,389' | 94' | Weld | Carr East | |
| 26 | Mellen Hill | 4290 | 6,351' | 403' | Rio Blanco | Mellen Hill |
| 27 | Flat Top | 4293 | 6,321' | 371' | Montrose | Red Rock Canyon |
| 28 | 6229 | 6,229' | 202' | Larimer | Carter Lake Reservoir | |
| 29 | "Smoky Hill Ridge" | 6,218' | 11' | Arapahoe | Piney Creek | |
| 30 | Atkinson Mesa | 4312 | 6,180' | 360' | Montrose | Red Canyon |
| 31 | Brushy Mountain | 4317 | 6,146' | 356' | Las Animas | Cobert Mesa North |
| 32 | Dalerose Mesa | 4320 | 6,107' | 319' | Las Animas | Dalerose Mesa |
| 33 | 6100 | 4323 | 6,100' | 1,000' | Mesa | Cameo |
| 34 | 6090 | 4325 | 6,090' | 312' | Larimer | Carter Lake Reservoir |
| 35 | "Mount Medaris" | 4326 | 6,086' | 306' | Garfield | New Castle |
| 36 | Tecolote Mesa | 4329 | 6,061' | 415' | Las Animas | Kim South |