| # | Name | Rank | Elevation | Prominence | Counties | Quadrangle |
| 1 | Spruce Knob | 1 | 4,865' | 2,799' | Pendleton | Spruce Knob |
| 2 | Thorny Benchmark | 2 | 4,860' | 1,720' | Pocahontas | Cass |
| 3 | Bald Knob | 3 | 4,860' | 920' | Pocahontas | Cass |
| 4 | Cheat Mountain | 4 | 4,860' | 480' | Pocahontas | Mingo |
| 5 | Reddish Knob | 46 | 4,397' | 2,003' | Augusta & Pendleton | Reddish Knob |