| # | Name | Rank | Elevation | Prominence | Counties | Quadrangle |
| 1 | Black Mountain | 406 | 2,650' | 2,300' | Washington | Shelving Rock |
| 2 | Frost Hill | 817 | 2,290' | 1,140' | Ontario | Bristol Springs |
| 3 | Tabor Benchmark | 875 | 2,244' | 1,054' | Livingston | Springwater |
| 4 | East Hill | 935 | 2,191' | 1,021' | Schoharie | Middleburgh |
| 5 | Yates County HP | 2,150' | 180' | Yates | Prattsburg |