| List Rank | NJ Rank | Name | Elevation | Saddle | Prominence | Line Parent | Isolation | Proximate Parent | County | Quadrangle |
| 1 | 1 | High Point | 1,799' | 931' | 868' | Shawangunk Mountains (HP) | 24.13 | High Knob | Sussex | Port Jervis South - Map |
| 2 | 2 | Sunrise Mountain | 1,653' | 1,290' | 363' | High Point | 7.78 | High Point | Sussex | Branchville - Map |
| 3 | 4 | 1606 | 1,606' | 1,170' | 436' | Warren County HP | 10.95 | Sunrise Mountain | Sussex | Flatbrookville - Map |
| New Jersey State Line HP | 1,530' | 1,530' | 0' | High Point | 1.24 | High Point | Sussex | Port Jervis South - Map | ||
| 4 | 6 | Hamburg Mountains (HP) | 1,493' | 608' | 885' | Schunnemunk Mountain | 11.69 | Sunrise Mountain | Sussex | Hamburg - Map |
| Rattlesnake Mountain | 1,492' | 1,330' | 162' | 1606 | 1.44 | 1606 | Sussex | Culvers Gap - Map | ||
| Wawayanda Mountain | 1,470' | 1,250' | 220' | Hamburg Mountains (HP) | 4.30 | Hamburg Mountains (HP) | Sussex | Wawayanda - Map | ||
| 5 | 9 | 1410 | 1,410' | 1,030' | 380' | Hamburg Mountains (HP) | 6.02 | Hamburg Mountains (HP) | Sussex | Franklin - Map |
| Maple Hill | 1,270' | 1,230' | 40' | Taylor Mountain | 1.45 | Taylor Mountain | Sussex | Wawayanda - Map | ||
| 6 | 17 | Pochuck Mountain | 1,194' | 510' | 684' | Hamburg Mountains (HP) | 4.15 | Hamburg Mountains (HP) | Sussex | Hamburg - Map |
| Lookout Mountain | 1,173' | 990' | 183' | 1410 | 6.15 | Green Pond Mountain | Sussex | Stanhope - Map | ||
| 7 | 19 | 1164 | 1,164' | 850' | 314' | 1410 | 4.40 | Allamuchy Mountain | Sussex | Stanhope - Map |
| 8 | 21 | Pimple Hills | 1,150' | 650' | 500' | 1410 | 4.67 | 1410 | Sussex | Newton East - Map |
| 9 | 36 | Islee Benchmark | 990' | 590' | 400' | 1410 | 7.22 | 1606 | Sussex | Newton West - Map |
| 10 | 37 | 989 | 989' | 670' | 319' | High Point | 4.82 | Pochuck Mountain | Sussex | Unionville - Map |
| 11 | 39 | 922 | 922' | 590' | 332' | High Point | 2.05 | 1606 | Sussex | Lake Maskenozha - Map |
| 12 | 41 | Beaver Run Benchmark | 910' | 570' | 340' | Pimple Hills | 5.80 | Pimple Hills | Sussex | Branchville - Map |
| 13 | 43 | 890 | 890' | 590' | 300' | Beaver Run Benchmark | 1.96 | Beaver Run Benchmark | Sussex | Branchville - Map |
| Smiths Hill | 870' | 730' | 140' | Islee Benchmark | 4.62 | Islee Benchmark | Sussex | Newton East - Map | ||
| Cage Hill | 857' | 670' | 187' | Allamuchy Mountain | 3.04 | Allamuchy Mountain | Sussex | Stanhope - Map | ||
| 14 | 47 | 855 | 855' | 550' | 305' | Beaver Run Benchmark | 1.06 | Beaver Run Benchmark | Sussex | Branchville - Map |
| Sterling Hill | 850' | 750' | 100' | Pimple Hills | 1.14 | Pimple Hills | Sussex | Franklin - Map |